Skip to main content

Media

The problem with internet advertising

The latest casualty in advertising technology has caused a stir in the industry, but this is a problem that has been brewing since its inception. As regulators and ad-blocking takes its toll, what is happening to internet advertising?

The wave of ad-tech companies floated in 2014 is starting to look more than a little accident-prone.

At the time, digital marketing was seen as driving earnings ever upwards akin to search engine powerhouse Google.

But a growing number of profit warnings later, a new reality is starting to emerge.

Alex DeGroote, an analyst at Peel Hunt and fierce critic of the sector, believes many ad-tech companies raised money on the back of profits created in the embryonic digital advertising sector that were simply unsustainable.

Immediately following the floats, there were major macro changes to the sector, particularly regarding the regulation of fraud and, of course, the rise of ad-blocking.

These were especially devastating for the companies that had initially relied on such a young and loose industry.

The wild west of the web

“All of them had benefited from the wild west antics that existed in digital and online advertising and was almost entirely un-policed, characterised by gross levels of fraud until last year,” explained DeGroote.

In September 2015, digital marketing platform AppNexus went through a rigorous overhaul of page impressions to filter its inventory on the back of client complaints. It claimed that a huge slug of reported internet traffic and adverting impressions were suspect.

Various dubious techniques were cited, including bot traffic (faked non-human traffic, sometimes churning out thousands of sham impressions per minute), misleading ads or push advertising, where the browser is essentially hijacked by a rogue extension.

Read - What is ad-blocking?

In an unfortunate coincidence, shortly afterwards Adgorithms (LON:ADGO), which had until the third quarter of last year reported robust profits, further unsettled the market with a sudden loss warning.

Adgorithms floated at 133p but is currently priced at 16p. Investors lost 90% of their investment and the £20mln it raised at IPO looks like a lost cause.

Tightening regulation is another such issue facing the industry, as CrossRider (LON:CROS) cited yesterday.

In what DeGroote called an “unremittingly bleak” statement, CrossRider warned it will see a 25% drop in revenue and underlying profits this year. It blamed an increased and rapid alteration in regulation for the sudden change in its outlook.

Publicly, the company has cited tightened regulation to mobile subscriptions as the main hindrance.

The warning came just weeks after the company reassured investors it was looking to 2016 with “confidence and excitement.”

CrossRider

Ironically, the CrossRider’s own web site is blocked by my malware detector. A quick Google search will churn out results pointing to a “CrossRider Virus”, namely malware associated with certain extensions developed on its platform.

This is ‘pushed advertising’ through an often unwanted extension that infiltrates the browser.

A source close to the company confirmed that there were indeed extensions, developed on the platform before its IPO, associated with “push advertising”. The source said that CrossRider had chosen to cease monetising its extension advertising.

The company is working diligently to ensure malware isn’t developed on its platform, we were assured.

On the same day, Blinkx (LON:BLNX), the video search platform, reported losses of US$94mln.

Blinkx was infamously laid into by Harvard professor Ben Edelman in a blog post in 2014, in which he outlined his concerns over the practices of the company, called “The Darker Side of Blinkx”.

Edelman raised serious questions about the group’s business model and revenue reporting.

He accused several of Blinkx’s acquisitions of generating revenues by billing clients for inflated traffic and user impressions.

The video advertising group has never really recovered from it. The day it was published, Blinkx shares fell by more than 30%. Edelman’s exposé foreshadowed what was to come for many of these ad-tech companies, as an industry in its infancy started to mature.

The problem with ad-blocking and regulation runs much deeper than a battle between consumers and advertisers. It runs to the core of the industry itself.

But companies using the platforms also need to take a long hard look at where their content is appearing; as the experts have shown, the advertisers are not always innocent victims.

But what now?

It seems trusted publishers such as Google could step in and regulate it themselves. Analyst Andrew Darley of finnCap believes that the whole sector is such a minefield and only giants like Google will succeed.

No doubt they have the capacity to work round ad-blocking software, but it seems it would be in the best interest of publishers to work with the ad-blockers. After all, it’s what the consumer wants.

Dedicated “white-lists” of pre-approved advertisers would act as a much needed quality control benefiting both the publisher and the user alike.

In a note by broker Liberum, analysts estimate that over US$20bn of advertising spending has already been lost to ad blockers. That figure is expected to rise to US$41bn in the next two years.

Publishers take action

They found that marketers were paying for a third of ads that have zero opportunity of being viewed. Publishers are already starting to take the matter into their own hands.

UK media platforms such as Channel 4 and ITV now won’t allow users to view content if they detect the use of an ad blocker, and other publishing outlets, such as the New York Times and the Guardian, are trialling pay-walls and subscription services in place of advertising.

But those are difficult waters to traverse, as DeGroote explains: “Publishers generally have two levels of income - subscription and advertising. It is notoriously hard to get users to pay for subscription online, unless you’re the likes of Netflix and Amazon.”

Digital is too big to fail, remember. Ad-blocking is no doubt one of the biggest challenges faced by the digital sector. For the publishers of the free content we all take for granted, advertising just isn’t working as it used to anymore.

*Blinkx and CrossRider were contacted directly but were unavailable for comment*

Read: We need to talk about ad-blocking