RBC Capital Markets has cut its price target for Antofagasta, the FTSE 100 Chilean copper miner, to 2,900p from 3,400p and kept its underperform rating.
The new target sits about 5% below Monday's closing price of 3,049p.
The bank said it had considered upgrading the shares after their recent fall but decided it was too early, given a lack of near-term catalysts and the risk that the artificial intelligence (AI) trade unwinds further.
It prefers Atalaya Mining, the Spanish copper producer, which it rates outperform with a 1,300p target, implying a total return of 59%.
AI flows lifted copper miners
Analysts Ben Davis and Laura Chan said large, liquid copper stocks such as Antofagasta and BHP had benefited this year from record copper prices.
The rally was driven by stockpiling in the US and weak mine supply.
But the miners' valuations also rose as money poured into thematic funds that buy companies seen as benefiting from AI, which include big copper producers.
Antofagasta's shares rose to a record valuation of about 12 times enterprise value to earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation (EV/EBITDA), a measure that compares a company's total value, including debt, with its operating profit.
That multiple has fallen to 9.3 times as AI stocks sold off after the US mid-term elections and questions over Jensen Huang's position at Nvidia.
RBC said the recent fall in Nvidia's market value, about $1.8 trillion, was larger than the value of the entire listed mining sector, at about $1.5 trillion.
If the AI sell-off continues and Antofagasta returns to its pre-2025 multiple of 7 times, its valuation could fall a further 25%, before any impact from a lower copper price.
The analysts said they were not AI bears, but a bursting capital spending bubble would hit copper and copper shares hard.
They added that investors had lost patience with Antofagasta's repeated guidance downgrades.
The miner will also lose its status as the only large copper company listed in London once Anglo American completes its merger with Teck Resources.
Atalaya offers more cushion
RBC said Atalaya's shares had not risen as sharply, which gives investors more protection if copper prices fall.
If copper dropped 20% from current levels, Atalaya would trade at 4 times 2027 EV/EBITDA, compared with 13.9 times for Antofagasta.
The bank trimmed its Atalaya target from 1,350p after updating its forecasts for third-quarter results and the Tharsis acquisition.
Its main catalyst is approval for the Touro copper project in north-west Spain, which would double Atalaya's output to 100,000 tonnes a year.