Bellway has been downgraded to 'hold' from 'buy' by Jefferies, which believes investors will find better risk and reward elsewhere among UK housebuilders.
The broker cut its price target to 2,472p from 2,527p, leaving upside of about 9%.
Jefferies said the shares look cheap at 0.7 times 2027 price to net tangible asset value (P/NTAV), which compares market value with the book value of physical assets.
However, it said Bellway is no cheaper than larger, more liquid rivals.
The broker remains positive on the sector and described the move as a relative call.
It noted that Bellway expects fewer sales outlets in its 2027 financial year, guiding to an average of 230 compared with 238 previously.
That leaves rivals better placed to step up delivery, according to the analysts.
Jefferies said its own margin forecasts now look generous.
Hitting the middle of Bellway's volume guidance would require it to double bulk sales and lift open market selling rates by around 10%, the broker calculated.
Lower pricing, dilution from bulk deals and build cost inflation are expected to weigh on margins, partly offset by 70 basis points of cost savings.
Jefferies now expects operating margins of 8.1% in 2027, down from 8.3%.
It trimmed earnings per share forecasts by 3% for 2027 and 6% for 2028.
Return on capital employed (ROCE) is forecast to stay below Bellway's cost of capital, while return on equity reaches only 7% by 2030.
The broker said that would limit how far the shares can re-rate relative to peers.
Bellway plans to return £225 million to shareholders across 2027 and 2028, helped by releasing cash tied up in work in progress and land.
The shares were off 1% at 2,272p in early trading.